Melodic, Thrifty & Chic
  • Fashion Blog
  • Music Blog
  • About Me
  • Contact
  • Press
  • SPONSOR/DONATE
  • SHOP MY CLOSET!

I Have Been Disqualified by Cotton in The Road To The Runway Contest & No One Seems to Know Why....

2/13/2013

14 Comments

 
Picture
Final Round, Day 8 (2/12/13) at 11:31 AM - Just Before Voting Officially Ended

What a wonderful Valentine's gift: to be told that my prize is going to someone who clearly lost due to a "hunch" that there was cheating on my behalf. I should have known this was all too good to be true.

Just in case you hadn't been following the final round closely, I've provided a snap shot I took at 11 AM on the final day of voting (Feb. 12). I took this right after my mom called me and told me that she couldn't vote for me anymore, because they had put up a splash screen saying that voting was over.

I don't know if this was the final count or not. It's probably pretty close, but this was where the votes were the last time I had voted for myself that morning. I just left my browser open.

To anyone who sees the vote totals, it seems pretty clear that I am the winner. So, my friends and family were shocked to learn that I had been disqualified for "robotic" voting. Only my father wasn't surprised. My mother had started calling up my family in Jamaica and telling them that I had won and he told her to wait until Cotton had updated their webpage. My dad is not an optimist. I get my pessimism from him. Hehe. He thought Cotton would try to do something strange and he wasn't holding his breath. Needless to say, he's not surprised, but I am still shocked.  Not even Cotton's IP Coordinator, Heather Snyder, seems to know what is going on. When I spoke to her on the phone, she seemed lost and confused. She was unable to meaningfully articulate the process by which I was disqualified. She promised to send me an email that would better explain the situation.

I thought something was not quite right when I looked at the numbers for my opponent over the course of the voting period, but I didn't say anything. My rate of votes was very good in comparison and I was still holding on. As I mentioned before, I've had an IT specialist keep track of the voting for me ever since I complained to Cotton about cheating during the second round.  I have spreadsheets galore.

Picture
My complaint to Cotton during the second round of voting in January 2013.

When I made this complaint, Cotton did not even acknowledge the possibility of fraudulent voting. Instead, I received a response which basically made me feel as if the status quo was my fault because I wasn't "rallying my network of friends" as much as I could have. The fact of the matter is, I was rallying everyone I knew. I had hundreds of people voting for me. It was clear that my opponent was cheating.


It was only after I had publicly complained that I noticed Cotton put in a stop-gap Captcha and then finally the Re-Captcha. After that, my opponent could not keep up with my rate of votes. I surpassed her and I went on to the third round. Another thing that helped me a great deal was this email response from Cotton informing me that votes were unlimited and that opening and closing one's browser to continuously vote was A-OK. I circulated that email to everyone I knew and they came through for me.

Picture
Email response from Cotton after I complained about cheating. (Click to view larger image)

Just before the end of the second round of voting, Cotton sent another email to all contestants informing them that they had detected fraudulent voting and that they would be adjusting the votes at the end of the voting period. I circulated this email to all of my friends and family as well. Keep in mind that, at this point, I had over 8,000 votes (more than I ever expected to have), because my friends voted for me for 10+ hours to help me overcome my opponent's inflated vote totals. No one from Cotton lodged an accusation of fraudulent voting in my region. Clearly, I had received an outpouring of support and I am sure that many people voted for me constantly and as often as they could, but this did not raise any suspicions. Why should it? I simply rallied my family and friends as I was told to do. I informed them of the unlimited voting system that was given Cotton's blessing and they voted their hearts out.

Picture
Email from Cotton about the detection of fraudulent votes during the second round. At this time, I had atleast 8000 votes and I know for a fact that my friends and family were voting for me dozens of times whenever they could get a chance. (Click to view larger image)

So, in the midst of pretty rampant and obvious cheating, not just in my region, but in many others, (see the example from the Northeast below - both contestants disappeared from the third and final round of voting) I went on to the final round. With the Re-Captcha in place, I felt super confident that I would win.

I knew that I typically get at least 3,000 votes before the end of each voting period and sure enough I hit that 3,000 mark and gradually surpassed it. My opponent had garnered more than 4,000 votes in the second round, but he was unable to maintain that level of votes in the third round. Curiously, his opponent in the second round had more than 6,000 votes, but she quietly disappeared and was not my opponent for the third round. She had garnered more than 11,000 votes in the first round and I had suspected cheating in her case. I mentioned that anomaly in this post from January. 

This is long before Cotton even had Captchas. The first round had no Captcha system whatsoever! This whole contest was flawed from the start. I was just determined to do my best under the circumstances. According to the IT specialist I mentioned earlier, the rate of votes on my side in the final round were such that my opponent would not have been able to surpass me.

By the end of the third round, I had a 900 vote lead.

So, Cotton is basically telling me that I had a robot vote more than 900 times in order to win the final round. This makes absolutely no sense at all given my track record in the previous two rounds and on top of the fact that I complained about cheating (probably not the only one) and spearheaded the introduction of the more effective Captcha system! How on earth, why on earth would I even need to cheat when I've consistently racked up at least 3,000 votes from the VERY beginning?

Picture
Two contestants with unusually high numbers who were disqualified from the third and final round.

These two contestants were disqualified in the third round. To compensate, the other two contestants were simply placed in a head-to-head with each other for a second time. I remember, because I was voting for Holly D. in the Northeast. I even posted this photo on my Facebook page the day that I got an email from Cotton about the detection of fraudulent votes and I opined that Cotton was referring to these two ladies. They had both disappeared from the running in the third round and I commented about that as well on my Facebook page. This is all well documented.
Curiously, the contestant who had been winning in the third round, Holly D., disappeared and Natalie C (above) is now on the front page of Cotton's website as the winner! What in the world is going on here!? Was this contest rigged?**

Now that I think of it, Hallie S. wasn't winning either. I'm sure of it. The girl with the maxi dress on, Lauren H., from the West Coast competition was winning. I was voting for Hallie, but Lauren was really far ahead. However, Hallie is on the front page and not Lauren. Very selective, Cotton.

Really? I'm the one who is being disqualified for cheating while Natalie C. is magically allowed to win the Grand Prize after not even competing in the third round and clearly cheating! 36,000 votes is just unprecedented! It's crazy! This is complete madness. If Cotton is going to have the gall to ruin my reputation by disqualification, then I want to see the proof! Until then, I am the legitimate winner and they have unjustly enriched my losing competitor. There is still time for Cotton to make this right.

I'm waiting, but like my wise father, I am not holding my breath. What a farce.

Picture

Would I even want to be on the same stage as some of these people, anyway? It seems that some of them really don't deserve to be up there, right now. There's a dark cloud on this whole event.

**Update: I spoke to Holly D. and she told me that Natalie C. was in the final round and that Natalie beat her. Maybe there was a glitch on Cotton's website, but that's not what I saw and everyone else I told about this issue at that time didn't see Natalie C., either. So, that one is a mystery. 2/16/13**


Follow on Bloglovin
14 Comments
krista
2/13/2013 12:07:20 pm

I'm so sorry this happened! It's terrible if the just put who they think had the "best" look for them. I hope you win the battle because the good guy has to win sometimes! fingers crossed for you.

Reply
Anna
2/14/2013 02:15:25 am

Thanks, Krista! I don't recognize your name, so you must be new to my blog. I have only a small following as I just started my blog last summer. ;) I'll be sure to take a look at your blog. I'm always looking for new people to follow! Cheers! <3

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
babette link
2/13/2013 03:33:11 pm

oh, damn. well, every dark cloud has its...oh, shut up! anyway, I voted for you. happy, uncottoncloudy valentine's day :)

Reply
Anna
2/14/2013 02:16:08 am

Haha. This made me smile. You have a knack for that, Babette. <3

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
Keit link
2/13/2013 09:15:35 pm

Hmmm, this is rather strange indeed. It may be rigged, or it is possible that people who were in charge of this contest had no idea what to do...I've seen it a thousand times, they just do whatever they wish without thinking it through, or do nothing at all, because they don't care..
About Natalie C....she would have so many votes, if she has a lot of followers on her blog and facebook, especially facebook....36, 000 votes is not a lot if you have 1000 followers..
Very sorry you didn't win, but that's why I don't enter giveaways or any contests, most of the time they're rigged -_-

Reply
Anna
2/14/2013 02:38:09 am

You're right. 36,000 votes isn't impossible. However, I was following the votes in Natalie's region pretty closely as I was voting for Brandhyze. Natalie had at least 10,000 votes and Brandhyze only had 4,000. I felt kind of sorry for her, actually. Then all of a sudden the votes were 36,000 v. 47,000 in favor of Brandyze. It was total insanity. No one had ever gotten votes that high in the entire month that this competition has been going on.

Both contestants were disqualified and neither competed in the third round. However, Natalie is now on the front page as a winner? Even more insanity. I still can't believe this is even happening. I couldn't sleep. I've received an incredible outpouring of support, however; andI am confident that there will be a silver lining to all of this.

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
Bianca link
2/14/2013 12:21:33 am

Anna, same thing happened to me. I was winning versus Grant in the second round for the midwest I had about 600 more votes than him before polling closed, then I got that same bogus email about cheating and the deducted 3800 of my votes!! And then he went against you. I feel like this goes beyond concindental, it was wrong and even racist what cotton did to us!! I worked so hard for this contest for it to get taken away and be a fraud. Like you I had family and friends working towards my win. I even had people risk their job to vote for me. Even my old high school was voting. Anyway, I would like to build a petition against this contest, and post it on reddit. If you would like to be apart of it, please email me and we can talk further! usagiskitchen (at) gmail.com

Reply
Anna
2/14/2013 02:24:00 am

I sent you an email Bianca. Let's work together to make things right.

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
Lucy link
2/14/2013 06:08:24 am

I really hate those competition because it always seems to me than they are cheating during it. I am really sorry for you and for me you are the winner. :)

Reply
Anna
2/14/2013 06:49:55 am

Thank you so much, Lucy! I can always count on your kindness. <3

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
Chrissi link
2/16/2013 01:27:36 pm

Wow, this whole situation seems like such a nightmare. I'm so sorry you have to deal with this!

Reply
Anna
2/16/2013 04:54:17 pm

Thanks, Chrissi. =/ Yeah, the consensus among my friends seems to be that Cotton just wanted a guy in the line-up. I also learned that this guy didn't even want to be in the running in the first place. His friend took the photo of him and posted it herself. Yeah. He didn't even take the time to post his own photo. It's ridiculous.

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply
Matea link
2/18/2013 06:07:59 pm

Im really sorry for that, that´s not fair! :(

Reply
Anna
2/19/2013 04:33:11 am

No, it's not. It has been almost six days now and I have yet to hear anything from Cotton. I still have trouble sleeping, because of it. What hurts the most is that they would malign my reputation so quickly and easily and they can't even bother to meaningfully explain why. =/

(\__/)
(=‘.’=)

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.





    (\__/)
    (=‘.’=)
    


    Hi! I'm Anna <3

    I'm fond of artistic fashion, esoteric music, retro games (the older the platform, the better), delectable noms, good libations, my Maine Coon, Bonaparte, and my Tabby, Winsome.

    Also, I attended university in Hyogo Prefecture and I am proficient in Japanese.


    もし、あなたは日本語が話せる、あたしに日本語で話て下さい!練習が必要だ!*^_^*
    



    (\__/)
    (=‘.’=)


    FTC DISCLOSURE:

    I may receive a small commission for purchases from shop links and banners displayed on my blog. 
    

    COPYRIGHT NOTICE:

    Text, graphics, and HTML code on this site are protected by U.S. and international copyright laws, and may not be copied, reprinted, published, translated, hosted, or otherwise distributed by any means without permission!


    © 2012 - 2022 melodicthriftychic.com
    


    Special Thanks To My Past Sponsors!
    ​

    Choies

    Persunmall

    Sammydress

    Barter's Closet

    Iconemesis

    Oasap

    SammyIcon

    TrendyFine

    Fiery Finish Vintage

    Sock It To Me

    Karina Dresses


    Foxtales Boutique

    Dressin.com

    Happiness Boutique

    Yoins

    Fashion Mia

    Newchic

    CNDirect

    Octer

    Sunglass.LA

    Tobi


    My Cure For Insomnia

    
    Sweet Tweets

    Tweets by @annab34r

    Stalker Paradise

    Follow on Bloglovin
    Follow on Bloglovin


    Picture

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture


    OMFG, Bro! Blog Button! Use It! <3


    These Shops
    Kick Ass <3




    My Sordid Past

    May 2022
    April 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021
    November 2019
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    August 2012

    Tag! You're It!

    All
    A Trip Down Memory Lane
    Autumn Style
    Awesome T Shirts
    Blogger Spotlight Series
    Cotton Road To The Runway Contest Is A Sham
    Featured Sale Items
    Giveaways
    On Line Shopping Reviews
    Post Apocalyptic And Futuristic
    Press Clippings
    Random Music
    Special Offers And Coupons
    Spring Style
    Style Advice
    Style Challenges
    Summer Style
    Vintage Treasures
    Wanderlust
    Winter Style
    Wish Lists

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.